Thinking about adding a Subaru Crosstrek to your driveway? You’re probably wondering if these popular all-wheel-drive subcompact SUVs will stick with you through thick and thin. With their rugged looks and adventure-ready marketing, Crosstreks certainly make big promises – but do they deliver when it comes to reliability? Let’s cut through the hype and examine what owners and experts have to say.
How Reliable Are Subaru Crosstreks According to Expert Ratings?
The Subaru Crosstrek has earned impressive reliability scores from major rating organizations, particularly in recent years.
The 2025 Crosstrek earned a solid 83/100 in J.D. Power’s Quality and Reliability assessment, while Consumer Reports included both the 2024 and 2025 Crosstreks on their “10 Top Picks” list – a strong endorsement of their reliability and overall quality.
RepairPal gives the Crosstrek an exceptional 4.5 out of 5 rating, ranking it first among compact SUVs for reliability. This translates to fewer shop visits and lower repair costs compared to competitors.
Here’s how the Crosstrek stacks up against industry averages:
| Reliability Factor | Subaru Crosstrek | Industry Average |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Repair Cost | $492 | $521 |
| Repair Frequency | 0.3 visits per year | 0.4 visits per year |
| Severe Repair Probability | 10% | 12% |
Best and Worst Subaru Crosstrek Model Years for Reliability
Not all Crosstrek model years are created equal when it comes to reliability. Knowing which generations shine and which struggle can save you headaches down the road.
Most Reliable Crosstrek Model Years
2021-2025 Models: The newest Crosstreks show significant improvement over earlier generations. The 2021 model introduced the optional 2.5L engine, solving many of the power complaints that plagued earlier versions. These models have:
- Higher J.D. Power scores (81-85/100)
- Fewer reported issues on NHTSA databases
- Enhanced build quality with the updated Subaru Global Platform
The 2024-2025 models benefit from the most recent redesign, featuring a 10% stiffer chassis and improved safety systems, making them the most dependable choices available.
Crosstrek Years to Avoid
2018-2019 Models: These years have the highest number of NHTSA complaints (205-301) and multiple recalls. Common problems include:
- Windshield cracks
- Battery drain issues
- Electrical system failures
- Engine stalling concerns
2013-2017 First-Generation Models: The earliest Crosstreks faced several reliability challenges:
- CVT transmission hesitation
- Key ignition problems
- Power steering failures
- Excessive road noise
Common Subaru Crosstrek Problems and Their Repair Costs
Understanding the typical issues that affect Crosstreks can help you budget properly and know what to look for when shopping used models.
Windshield Cracks
This is perhaps the most widespread complaint, especially in 2018-2021 Crosstreks. Owners report cracks developing seemingly without impact, often starting near the EyeSight camera housing.
Typical repair cost: $1,000-$1,500 (including EyeSight recalibration)
Battery and Electrical Issues
Many 2014-2019 Crosstrek owners have experienced:
- Premature battery failures
- Unexpected battery drain
- Faulty alternators
- Dashboard electrical glitches
Typical repair cost: $200-$700 depending on the specific electrical problem
CVT Transmission Problems
Earlier models (2013-2017) sometimes experience:
- Hesitation during acceleration
- “Rubber-band” feeling when changing speeds
- Overheating during extended hill climbs
Typical repair cost: $3,500-$7,000 for transmission replacement (though many issues can be addressed with a CVT fluid change costing around $250)
Long-Term Maintenance Costs for Subaru Crosstreks
How much should you expect to spend keeping your Crosstrek on the road over time? CarEdge estimates that Crosstrek owners will spend about $8,475 on maintenance during the first 10 years of ownership.
That breaks down to around $850 per year during the later years, with a 24.76% chance of needing a major repair during that decade. While not the lowest in the class, these costs remain competitive.
Here’s a breakdown of expected maintenance milestones:
| Mileage | Maintenance Services | Approximate Cost |
|---|---|---|
| 30,000 miles | Oil change, filters, brake inspection | $150-$250 |
| 60,000 miles | Above plus CVT fluid change, spark plugs | $450-$650 |
| 90,000 miles | Above plus brake fluid, differential fluid | $600-$800 |
| 105,000 miles | Major service including timing belt (H6 models) | $1,200-$1,500 |
How Many Miles Will a Subaru Crosstrek Last?
With proper maintenance, Crosstrek owners can expect their vehicles to last 200,000+ miles. Many owners on Reddit forums report their Crosstreks running strong well beyond 150,000 miles with just routine maintenance.
The Crosstrek’s longevity tends to be better than many competitors in the subcompact SUV segment, thanks to:
- Simpler, time-tested boxer engine design
- Robust all-wheel-drive system
- Solid build quality (especially for post-2020 models)
That said, reaching these high mileage markers depends heavily on:
- Following the maintenance schedule rigorously
- Addressing small issues before they become major problems
- Avoiding the problematic model years mentioned earlier
How the Crosstrek Compares to Other Subaru Models
Curious how the Crosstrek’s reliability stacks up against other members of the Subaru family? Here’s how it compares:
| Model | RepairPal Rating | Annual Repair Cost | Major Repair Probability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crosstrek | 4.5/5 | $492 | 10% |
| Forester | 3.5/5 | ~$632 | 14% |
| Outback | 3.5/5 | $607 | 13% |
| Impreza | 4.0/5 | $503 | 11% |
The Crosstrek generally outperforms its Subaru siblings in reliability metrics, thanks to its simpler design and more recent platform updates.
What Crosstrek Owners Say About Reliability
Real-world feedback from Crosstrek owners provides valuable insights beyond the statistics:
“It handles Canadian winters better than any vehicle I’ve driven,” notes one Reddit user, highlighting the Crosstrek’s all-weather capability.
Many owners praise:
- Low maintenance requirements
- Consistent performance in extreme weather
- Comfortable ride quality
- Excellent ground clearance for light off-roading
Common criticisms include:
- Underpowered base engine (pre-2021 models)
- Wind noise at highway speeds
- Limited cargo space compared to larger SUVs
- Overactive driver assistance features
Checking Crosstrek Reliability Before Buying Used
If you’re shopping for a used Crosstrek, here’s what to look for to ensure you get a reliable example:
- Check for recalls: Use the NHTSA database to verify all recalls have been addressed, especially for 2018-2019 models which had several important safety recalls.
- Windshield integrity: Carefully inspect the windshield for cracks, particularly around the EyeSight camera housing area.
- Test the electrical system: Make sure all electronics work properly, including the infotainment system and all power accessories.
- CVT performance: During the test drive, pay close attention to how the transmission behaves during acceleration and at various speeds.
- Service history: Look for documented maintenance records showing consistent care, particularly CVT fluid changes every 60,000 miles.
- Consider certified pre-owned: Subaru’s certified pre-owned program includes additional warranty coverage that can provide peace of mind.
Bottom Line: Is the Subaru Crosstrek Reliable?
Yes, the Subaru Crosstrek is generally a reliable vehicle, especially the 2021 and newer models. With strong ratings from major reliability assessors, reasonable maintenance costs, and high owner satisfaction, it represents a solid choice in the subcompact SUV segment.
For maximum reliability:
- Choose 2021 or newer models if your budget allows
- Avoid the problematic 2018-2019 model years
- Follow the maintenance schedule diligently
- Address small issues promptly before they escalate
The Crosstrek offers a compelling blend of all-weather capability, practicality, and dependability that explains its growing popularity among both urban commuters and outdoor enthusiasts. While no vehicle is perfect, the Crosstrek’s strong reliability record makes it a smart choice for those wanting a versatile, long-lasting SUV.
